I never thought of Michelle Dockery for the Doctor! I looked up that film on Youtube and I think you’r e right she would have been realy cool in the part. DA probably made her a little too famous? I’d like to see her inthe part at some point so I hope that happens. You might laugh but I think Keira Knightly could pull it off too. Whats something you hope to see happen with the new Doctor?

I’m not laughing, I think KK probably could do it, but, again, just too famous at this point (but who knows).  I think Sophie Okonedo would be brilliant – though she has been in Who before (Liz X), it isn’t a write-off.  

I hope the new Doctor gets to visit some old companions (from the classic era) – we’ve done all the classic baddies, it’s time to visit old friends.  I’d also like to see Romana return – in the series she was left in E-space, but it’d be interesting to see how she might have made her way back.  

On the same theme, I do hope Capaldi gets to see Susan at Christmas.  

OK DOC we’re getting a female Doctor what do you think of Whittaker? I don’t know her except Broadchurch. I hoped for Tilda Swinton cuz she’s a little weird or like Helene Bonham Carter who would be bonkers, I think.

I’m not that familiar with her, either, but I think that could be a good thing.  I do think Swinton and Carter could have pulled it off, but I don’t think they were ever in the cards. They’re too well-known and it would be hard to separate their own eccentricities from ‘The Doctor.’   

One idea I had was Michelle Dockery – before she did Downton Abbey, though. She was quite Doctor-y in Hogfather and I thought she’d be a strong choice.  

I’m looking forward to Whittaker’s version and hope they keep Pearl Mackie as a companion – even if only part-time.